Related
Summary
When check a moviemusical , one ask impeccable vocalizing , but that ’s not always the case . Sometimes , even gifted actors without much telling experience deliver rather unpleasant performances . After all , musicals live or die on the outspoken artistry of their casting . In the kingdom of stage production , frail voices might slip by unnoticed amidst the wholesale spectacle , but the intimacy of movie leaves subpar tattle starkly exposed . Despite the demands , ill - equipped stars often plug roles for their box function ingathering rather than for their vocal talent . However , their deficient singing carrying out place upright out conspicuously .
FromGerard Butler ’s rendition ofPhantom of the Opera ’s soar aria to Pierce Brosnan ’s rough try atMamma Mia ! , lack gift has drop many lavish musicals . Even icon like Tom Cruise struggled to convincingly sway out inRock of Ages . While fans may ab initio rejoice at the mess of their favorites on blind , their off - Francis Scott Key crooning shatters the fantasy . These inharmonic efforts link up a tuneless hall of infamy , underscoring that musicals rely first on svelte performers who can adeptly carry a melody . Otherwise , or else of swimmingly gliding aspiration , audiences are left with embarrassing nightmares .
10Pierce Brosnan in Mamma Mia! (2008)
Portrays Sam Carmichael
Brosnan ’s outspoken limitations prevented him from seamlessly meld with the iconic ABBA melodies .
Renowned for his role as cinema ’s smoothest secret agent , Pierce Brosnan venture into the melodious genre . Set against the upbeat ABBA soundtrack , the lighthearted film in the Greek Isles features an impressive ensemble mould , though most are n’t know for their singing abilities . portray one ofthree potential fathers to Sophie , Brosnan delivers his vocal public presentation alongside seasoned player like Meryl Streep and Colin Firth . However , lacking formal breeding , his labored tattle reveals a detectable deficiency in melodious talent . Despite his allegiance to the film ’s ambiance , Brosnan ’s vocal limitations prevented him from seamlessly go with the iconic ABBA melodic phrase .
9Will Smith in Aladdin (2019)
Portrays The Genie
Cast
In the live - action remake ofAladdin , Will Smith boldly steps into the iconic role of the Genie , antecedently portrayed by the legendary Robin Williams . While Smith ’s functioning fetch its own flair to the type , emulating Williams proves challenging . Nevertheless , Smith shoot the film with get-up-and-go and serves as its main high spot . However , his tattle fall short of expectation . Despite his ebullience , Smith ’s vocals lack the depth and mastery needed for the musical number , especially evident in tracks like " admirer Like Me . " yet , his personal magnetism shines through , providing a hopeful spot in one ofGuy Ritchie ’s best movies .
8John Travolta in Hairspray (2007)
Portrays Edna Turnblad
Travolta ’s interpretation lacked the necessary vocal prowess and persona .
The film adaptation of the lively Broadway musicalHairspraysparked disputation with the casting of John Travolta as lady of the house Edna Turnblad . Unlike the iconic portrayals by Divine in the original and Harvey Fierstein on microscope stage , Travolta ’s rendition lacked the necessary outspoken artistry and persona . Despite Travolta getting his start on Broadway , his lusterless delivery dampened the infectious energy of the grade , miss the vivacity and sass that fix the character . Despite a strong supporting cast , Travolta ’s performance felt more like a celebrity vanity projection than a fitting casting option .
7Cameron Diaz in Annie (2014)
Portrays Miss Hannigan
In the lacklusterAnnieremake , Cameron Diaz ’s portrayal of Miss Hannigan proved to be an unfitting swan Sung for her life history . Diaz , known for her limited melodic abilities , go wrong to pass off life into iconic numbers like " Little miss " and " Easy Street . " Her thin representative and inability to surrender potent vocals highlighted her struggle with the demand required for musical theater . Additionally , obvious autotuning stripped away the legitimacy of her fictional character , belittle the essence of the boozy and abrasive character . Diaz ’s carrying out lacked machination and joyousness , underscoring her ineptness for a theatrical role demanding strong musical prowess .
6Rebel Wilson in Cats (2019)
Portrays Jennyanydots
The movie version of Andrew Lloyd Webber’sCatsstands as one of the most criticized cinematic try in late memory . While delegate rap in its disastrous executing is challenging given its overall shortcomings , Rebel Wilson ’s portrayal of the African tea Jennyanydots emerge as a particularly weak link , specially in terms of musical operation . Amidst the unsettling digital fur impression , Wilson ’s rendering of campy numeral falls flat due to her shrill delivery . Unable to instill the absurdness with the intended spell , her lackluster vocals only aggravate the film ’s misstep . Wilson ’s performance becomes an unfortunate painful distributor point , further contributing to the moving picture ’s inharmoniousness .
They might have the glitz and glamour of a big melodious production with catchy Song and elaborated sets , but some musicals can get pretty eery .
5Seth Rogan in The Lion King (2019)
Portrays Pumbaa
Billy Eichner and Seth Rogen portray the meerkat - warthog duo Timon and Pumbaa in the live - actionThe Lion King . While Eichner delivers solid vocal music , Rogen struggle with the melodious numbers , his voice lacking glossiness and pitch shot accuracy . Despite his entertaining line readings as Pumbaa , Rogen ’s singing , particularly in the dear song " Hakuna Matata , " falls flat . His falter vocalization often misses the mark , fail to harmonize in effect with Eichner ’s bright whole step . While hurtle choice share some incrimination , Rogen ’s shortcoming underscore the remaking ’s larger exit : drain vibrant songs of their verve through misguided rendition .
4Gerard Butler in Phantom of the Opera (2004)
Portrays Erik The Phantom of the Opera
The 2004 film relied too heavily on Gerard Butler ’s voice , lead in disastrous final result .
Another Andrew Lloyd Webber motion picture adaptation , The Phantom of the Opera , had trouble come up a lead man who could hit the demanding outspoken heights require for the role . alas , the 2004 film relied too to a great extent on Gerard Butler ’s voice , resulting in calamitous consequence . impersonate the disfigured specter haunting the Paris Opera , Butler keep dramatic chroma but die to fork out in beloved anthems like the form of address cartroad , with his vocals . Lacking classical proficiency and nuance , his functioning drained all beauty from the score . His casting seem more for marquee value than melodious ability , a huge misstep for a production demanding attainment .
3Tom Cruise in Rock of Ages (2012)
Portrays Stacee Jaxx
Cruise decrease little of truly moving audiences with a convincing vocal execution .
The whisker metal jukebox musical adaptationRock of Ageshas Tom Cruise take on the part of faded rock star Stacee Jaxx , a character seemingly tailor to his mavin office . Cruise certainly seem the part of the outlandish ' 80s rock ikon , to the full embracing the character . However , while he commits wholeheartedly to portraying a melodious frontman , Cruise ’s voice betray to match his bluster . His stifled tone and modified range lack the smooth , sleazy intensity ask . Despite his magnetic acting , Cruise accrue forgetful of truly moving audiences with a convincing outspoken performance that meet his dedicated portrayal .
2Russell Crowe in Les Misérables (2012)
Portrays Inspector Javert
Broadway ’s belovedLes Misérableshas Russell Crowe take on the role of police examiner Javert in the film adaptation , seemingly a perfect fit given his muscular screen presence . While the film is one ofRussell Crowe ’s best motion picture , his singing voice decrease inadequate compared to stellar vocalists like Hugh Jackman and Anne Hathaway . His vocals , lacking the emotional depth and range needed , pale in compare to his co - stars . Crowe ’s public presentation highlights a mismatch between character and performer , with his limitations becoming glaringly apparent in the emotionally demanding musical score ofLes Misérables .
1Clint Eastwood in Paint Your Wagon (1969)
Portrays Pardner
Eastwood ’s unparalleled mode of awkward crooning added a touch of entertainment , foreground the motion picture ’s mutual exclusiveness .
The interesting Western musicalPaint Your Wagonfeatured yammer western ikon Clint Eastwood and Lee Marvin as prospect mate , who oddly spend much of the photographic film engaging in prolonged song - and - saltation numbers . Neither player possessed solid musical abilities , with Eastwood notably struggling vocally , which clash with his tough , silent character . His try at " I Talk to the Trees " sound bitter and off - key . Eastwood ’s unequaled expressive style of awkward crooning add a touch of amusement , highlighting the celluloid ’s inconsistencies . While one ofEastwood ’s more interesting westerly characters , Paint Your Wagonis an unusual person where even the hard cowboy could n’t hit the right note .
