We Were Liars
Summary
Amazon is adapting E. Lockhart ’s best - selling young grownup bookWe Were Liarsfor the small screen , andthere are many thing the TV show must get right about the source material . We Were Liarshit shelves back in 2014 , and the novel became a hit , go on to pull ahead a Goodreads Choice Award , become a National Book Award finalist , and make the rubric of Printz Award honoree . The taradiddle follows Cadence Easton Sinclair as she reelect to her family ’s private island after a unknown incident two summertime ago allow for her with amnesia and a strained relationship with her good protagonist .
As Caddy spends more sentence on the island , she begins to piece together what happened two years ago — andWe Were Liars’ending turn in a devastating blow to everything she believes is dependable . Lockhart ’s novel know how to play with timeline and mysteries to storm the reader , andPrime Video ’s adaptationmust build on its strengths . That think of taking precaution to get certain thing about the source material right . After all , a television version ofWe Were Liarswon’t employment without the lineament that make the book enceinte .
6The We Were Liars Show Must Make Good Use Of Multiple Timelines
ManyTV show up master the function of multiple timeline , andWe Were Liarsmust become one of them for win on Prime Video . Since Caddy ’s past is so critical to her present - solar day timeline in the book , arrest the back and away between the two periods is a necessity for the Amazon show . That means include plenty of hints about what happened two summers ago in Caddy ’s current storyline — something Lockhart action impressively . It also requires theWe Were Liarsshow to capture the tincture of each summertime , with Caddy ’s retiring eliciting nostalgia and her present being defined by regret and heartbreak .
TV shows likeCruel SummerandThis Is Usare perfect lesson of how to juggle multiple timeline in a telly serial publication , andWe Were Liarscan easy learn from both . Cruel Summerdoes the foreshadowing and tonal shifts well , two thingsWe Were Liarsmust pull from its reservoir material . AndThis Is Usunderscores the grief of the nowadays by describe the past tense , which is similar to what Lockhart does in her YA book .
5We Were Liars Must Get The Characters & Relationships Right
We Were Liarshas a compelling central secret , butthe character and relationships are arguably the most of import component of Lockhart ’s book . Without Caddy being so easy to sympathize with and concern to , many reviewer would n’t be able to invest themselves in her storey . Likewise , Caddy ’s strained interactions with her fellowship and changing friendly relationship makeWe Were Liarsan emotional read long before the novel reveals its tragic twist . The Amazon show will postulate to write Caddy and her friends well , and it will take to cast thespian with good alchemy to cop down these moral force .
4We Were Liars' Setting Is Integral To Its Story
We Were Liarstakes place on a remote island , and its setting is integral to its report for multiple reasons . For one , the wealth and privilege of Caddy ’s family factor into how events open over the course of study of Lockhart ’s novel . The Amazon show could even expand on this element of the rootage material , using the Sinclair family unit ’s status to offer extra commentary throughout its runnel . On top of that , We Were Liars’island setting offer an air of nostalgia and counterpoint the book ’s darker themes . It ’s authoritative that theWe Were Liarsadaptation accomplishes all this with its setting , peculiarly if it hopes to be close to the book .
3Generational Trauma Must Play A Role In The We Were Liars Show
Although Caddy spends most ofWe Were Liarsholed up with her friends , her kin ’s constrained relationship and their involuntariness to address problem touch her character spark greatly . Generational harm is clearly present within the Sinclair family , and Lockhart ’s prequel novel , Family of Liars , confirms as much . The Amazon adaptation will need to showcase this to explain why Caddy is struggling with her amnesia , as well as why her family is n’t communicating with her . It will also factor out into the novel ’s end wind , as event unfold because of hereditary dramatic play .
This is another element ofWe Were Liarsthat Amazon can drudge deeper into , as the show may have more time to handle with the book ’s supporting quality . If the tv set serial succeeds in this area , it could also get green - lit for a time of year 2 or spinoff . After all , interest inWe Were Liarssuggests there would also be interest group in aFamily of Liarsadaptation later .
2Amazon Must Nail We Were Liars' Big Ending Twist
We Were Liarsdoes several things really well , butits end twist is plausibly the biggest testament to Lockhart ’s talent as an author . After leading readers to believe that everything is happening as Caddy relay it , the novel in the end reveals that she is n’t exactly a authentic narrator . clue from earlier start to make sense as readers realize that Caddy ’s interaction with her Friend in the present - twenty-four hour period timeline are n’t what they seem . And the ground that Caddy feels lost , lonesome , and isolated go far deeper than the normal hurting of develop up .
In addition to stick the landing place with this twist — something that will require Amazon to build a solid understructure for it and surprise TV audience — theWe Were Liarsshow must make the family fire scene as harrowing as it is in the script . Caddy and her friends burning down Clairmont is one of the most memorable moments from Lockhart ’s novel . It should be recreate in a way that makes it as intense and alarm as it is in the source stuff .
1Amazon’s Adaptation Needs To Convey The Feelings Of Grief
At its core , We Were Liarsis a leger about grief , and the Amazon adaptation must handle that radical with charge . This goes beyond scram the novel ’s major twist right wing , though that ’s for certain command to force home its subject matter about loss . However , the tactile sensation of grief looms over every chapter of Lockhart ’s book , and the adaptation should infuse that into each episode , too . to boot , theWe Were LiarsTV show must capture Caddy ’s inner dialogue and show how she intend to observe her friends go forward . These things will be worthwhile to trance , even if they exhibit a challenge on - screen .
Custom Image by Katarina Cimbaljevic
