Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
Summary
WithA New Hopebeing the first theatricalStar Warsmovie , George Lucas has since made many retcons to the film , mean Luke Skywalker ’s close roofy consist to him at several points throughout the story . When determine theStar Warsmovies in chronological order , A New Hopeis the 5th in the timeline , four when not countingRogue One : A Star Wars Story . However , it is no secret that George Lucas did not have the entirety of the now - expansive franchise design out whenA New Hopewas expel as simplyStar Warsin 1977 .
While theupcomingStar Warsmovieswill proceed to expand the enfranchisement under Disney , it is an interesting experience to look back upon the original trilogy with the sum up circumstance the prequels - and subsequence - provide . WhileStar Warshas always flourished in retcons , retrospective change , and interesting additions thanks to various movies andStar WarsTV shows , there is no denying that some elements of the original trilogy remain contradictory when view in the context of the entire saga . One such element is Luke Skywalker ’s early life , asthe farmhand is severalize a smattering of lies atStar Wars’onset .
Looking at all nine Skywalker Saga incoming and three spinoffs , we top the best Star Wars movie in our full ranking of the galaxy far , far out .
7Owen Tells Luke He Doesn’t Know If Obi-Wan Kenobi Exists Anymore
Future Star Wars stories, such as Obi-Wan Kenobi, make it clear that Owen lies about the Jedi.
One of the first lie Luke Skywalker is severalize inA New Hope ’s opening night , where most mistruths are commonly found , comes from Uncle Owen . Luke questions his auntie and uncle about the astromech droid they late bought . The droid , who has since become know as the lovably loyal R2 - D2 , says he belongs to someone named Obi - Wan Kenobi . After a glimpse between Beru and Owen , the latter country that Luke should get the droid ’s memory wiped , actuate Luke to query what happens if Obi - Wan comes look for him .
Owen then replies to Luke stating"He wo n’t . I do n’t think he exists anymore . “As is known from the widerStar Warsfranchise , this is a blatant lie by Owen . Owen is cognisant that Old Ben is Obi - Wan Kenobi , and is merely lie to Luke so that the latter does not search out the former and learn about his heritage . This is quickly followed by another , much more blatant , lie .
6Owen Tells Luke Obi-Wan Died At The Same Time As Anakin
Owen continues to lie about Obi-Wan Kenobi to protect Luke.
After telling Luke that Obi - Wan does not exist any longer , Owen gives his reasoning why . Luke ’s uncle says"He die about the same fourth dimension as your father . “Again , Owen is more aware than anyone that Ben is Obi - Wan Kenobi and that the former Jedi has been living on Tatooine for decades . The events of 2022’sObi - Wan Kenobimake it copiously clear that Owen and Kenobi spoke intermittently beforeA New Hope . However , Owen naturally wants nothing to do with Obi - Wan and wishes to protect Luke , explaining why he lied to his nephew about Kenobi being dead .
5Kenobi States He Doesn’t Remember Owning A Droid
Obi-Wan not remembering R2-D2 is nothing short of a travesty!
While Uncle Owen tells several lies about Obi - Wan Kenobi , the former Jedi himself is not opposed to forefend the truth when he is present to Luke . The most immediate lie Kenobi tells Luke is when he states he does not remember possess a droidafter R2 claims Obi - Wan is his owner . Given what is known of theStar Warsprequels , this is an obvious lie . While many have attempted to explicate this by claiming Obi - Wan ’s time on Tatooine has left his mind puddle , it is clear that he remembers many other element about his yesteryear in the moving picture .
In reality , it is simply the case that Lucas did not have the minute detail of theStar Warsprequels planned out when makingA New Hope . Lucas probably had broad story measure in mind , but R2 - D2 being a common companion of Obi - Wan Kenobi during the prequel trilogy was potential not something the auteur had in judgement when write the original plastic film ’s handwriting . Therefore , Kenobi say he does not remember R2 comes across as an confessedly foreign lie .
4Obi-Wan Implies Anakin Lived On Tatooine
Anakin’s history was heavily reshaped by the Star Wars prequels.
Another element ofA New Hopethat has been positioned as a lie thanks to otherStar Warsmovies is Obi - Wan ’s implication that Anakin lived on Tatooine . Luke claims that his father was not a warrior and was instead a navigator on a spice freighter . Obi - Wan Kenobi replies"That ’s what your uncle told you . He did n’t hold with your male parent ’s nonesuch . Thought he should ’ve stayed here and not gotten knotty . “This imply that Anakin , Obi - Wan , and Owen were somewhat near in the past and that the trio had disagreements about the Clone Wars .
However , as is sleep with from theStar Warsprequels , Anakin - much less Obi - Wan - hardly spent any meter on Tatooine with Owen . Obi - Wan ’s words inANew Hopemake it seem as though Anakin lived on Tatooine and left Owen behind to fight in the war , something that is very manifestly not true . Anakin endure on Coruscant from the years of nine and was raised as a Jedi , only meeting Owen oncefor a abbreviated moment inStar Wars : Episode II - Attack of the Clones .
3Obi-Wan Tells Luke That Anakin Wanted Him To Have His Lightsaber
Anakin’s lightsaber was never intended to be passed through generations.
afterwards in the aspect in Obi - Wan ’s hut inA New Hope , more mistruths are told . Obi - Wan convey out Anakin ’s lightsaber and tells Luke that his don require him to have it when he was one-time enough . This is , again , a statement that ostensibly comes from nothing . Anakin cash in one’s chips down his lightsaber to his tike is never advert inStar Wars : Episode III - Revenge of the Sith . If Obi - Wan had not take up up Anakin ’s saber after vote out him on Mustafar , Anakin likely would have continued to employ it as Darth Vader , and it never would have been handed to Luke .
2Obi-Wan States That Darth Vader Was A Jedi
What he said was true, from a certain point of view…
While not as overt a Trygve Lie as the others constitute in the film , Obi - Wan ’s words about Darth Vader are not exactly truthful . Obi - Wan states that a"young Jedi named Darth Vader … helped the Empire hunt down and destroy the Jedi Knights . “This incriminate that Darth Vader was the actual name of Obi - Wan ’s apprentice , as Lucas distinctly had not develop the Sith faith and the precursor of " Darth " for dark side acolytes at the sentence of composition .
Obi - Wan ’s words about Vader serve the Empire imply the organization was around before the Jedi Order died out , though Palpatine only spring the Empire after Order 66 .
1Obi-Wan Says Darth Vader Killed Luke’s Father
The biggest Star Wars lie resulted in an attempted retcon from Lucas.
Perhaps the most flagrant prevarication inA New Hope , so much so that it has even been retconned by Lucas in former films , is that Darth Vader killed Luke ’s father . Obi - Wan mentions Anakin at length to Luke in the first theatricalStar Warsfilm , prompting Luke to probe the one-time solitudinarian for more info . Kenobi tells Luke elements of Anakin ’s life that are reliable , such as that he was a great pilot and a foxy warrior . After mention that Anakin fought alongside Obi - Wan in the Clone Wars , Luke finally asks what pass off to his father .
It is still inherently a lie that Vader and Anakin were two unlike people .
After telling Luke about Darth Vader ’s betrayal , Obi - Wan states that the benighted sider"betrayed and murdered your don . “Again , the prequels make it evident that this is not true . While Lucas attempted to retcon the Trygve Halvden Lie inReturn of the Jediby take in Obi - Wan say that what he told Luke was true from a certain full point of view , it is still inherently a prevarication that Vader and Anakin were two different people .
Custom Image made by Lewis Glazebrook.
Since the release of the film in 1977,Star Wars’concept of the dark side has made it so that this is almost true . Lucas ’ later theme for the dark side is that the Sith variant of character are inherently unlike from their Jedi twin as exemplified by the like ofObi - Wan Kenobi’sfinale concerning Anakin . However , at the time ofA New Hope ’s release , Lucas did not have any of that planned , proving the dividing line to be one of many lies recount to young Luke Skywalker .
