Related
Summary
A geniusMCUtheory about the Infinity Stones suggests that the Snap was n’t actuallyThanos’idea . As seen in the MCU Infinity Saga , Thanos collects the powerful Infinity Stones with the commission to efface half of all life in the universe , thereby restoring balance to the universe and saving the living from overpopulation and the rapid depletion of resources . However , it ’s been suggested that Thanos did n’t devise this plan alone .
Thanos ' home universe of Titanwas lost due to a lack of imagination after its people rejected his proposal to stamp out half the universe at random . Thanos then became know as " The Mad Titan " before he was ultimately prove correct and his mass go out . As such , this actuate Thanos to start his drive across the Galax urceolata , killing half the population on various populace as a means of restoring " Libra " . However , a new MCU theory suggests that Thanos ' theme of obliterate one-half of all liveliness may have come from none other than the Mind Stone .
Want to catch up before the next release , or just revisit the universe for a refresher ? Here ’s the order to see the entire MCU timeline .
Theory: The Mind Stone Convinced Thanos To Wipe Out Half Of Existence
present by RedditorLoveWaffle1 , the idea is that the Mind Stone was the only Infinity Stone Thanos had before the issue ofAvengers : Infinity Warand the start of the Infinity Saga itself . After all , Thanos gives the Chitauri Scepter and the Mind Stone within to Loki to aid in his conquest of Earth in 2012’sAvengers . However , there is no canonical backstory for how and when Thanos have the Mind Stone to begin with .
continue that in mind , it ’s theorized that theMind Stone was in Thanos ' possessionfor quite some time . As such , it begin influencing his mind and perhaps even became responsible for the theme of pass over out one-half of all sprightliness to begin with , rather than a less homicidal pick like finding a way to generate extra resources that are n’t as finite . This would also excuse why Ultron decide to wipe out humanity and replace it with something potent , having been activate and tempt by the Mind Stone courtesy of Tony Stark and Bruce Banner .
Does This Idea Actually Work In The MCU Canon?
While an challenging idea , the primal element is the timing . For Thanos to have been convinced to wipe out one-half of all life by an exterior influence , the Mind Stone would have needed to be in his self-possession before events on Titan became dire . This means that Thanos would have involve to have the Mind Stone in his possession for age before finding the other stones .
While technically possible , it does n’t make much mother wit turn over his crusade where the Mad Titan started going from world to universe , wiping out 50 % of life one planetary population at a time without the other stones . However , the idea of theMind Stone not value life and affecting both Thanos and Ultronto hold the same dark values is still compelling , though it does give up questions regarding its apparent want of effect on the Vision . irrespective , a possible origin for the Mind Stone does stand its perversive nature .
Between Marvel Studios and Sony Pictures Entertainment , here is every upcoming Marvel movie release particular date and what we have it off about the project so far .
An MCU-Connected Thanos Novel Supports The Mind Stone’s Corruption (Sort Of)
The noncanonical yet MCU - adjacent novelThanos : Titan Consumedby Barry Lyga support the theme that the Mind Stone had a perversive influence . It also let out a likely backstory for how Thanos came to own his first Infinity Stone . InTitan Consumed , Thanos was already conquering worlds in his crusade for balance when he heard rumour of the Infinity Stones ' existence .
Having in the beginning dismissed the Infinity Stones as Asgardian myth , Thanos began seeking them out . This put him in impinging with the Mind Stone ’s original owner have intercourse as the Lorespeaker , brother to the Grandmaster and Collector . Upon the Lorespeaker ’s expiry , Thanos remains in his quarter studying the Mind Stone for an elongated period of weeks , only to egress with his eyes having been change with burn purple muscularity which ultimately fade over fourth dimension ( explaining the difference of opinion in his appearance inGuardians of the Galaxycompared toInfinity War ) .
This implies a sorting of influence the Mind Stone might have had over Thanos , albeit without any sort of clear specificity as Thanos was already look for correspondence via randomize murder . If anything , the Mind Stone in all probability urged Thanos to find and bring together the other Stones with an increased fixation and fanaticism . However , it ’s important to remember that this novel was only connected to the MCU as an next write up , rather than being any kind of official canon .
How The Mind Stone Theory Changes Thanos' Backstory
" The Mind Stone being a pestiferous power behind Thanos ' origins is still a adept thought and would have had some fundamental narrative significance . "
If even proven lawful , this possibility would for certain create some plot holes and question regarding the Mind Stone ’s influence or lack thereof on heroes such as Vision , Quicksilver , or the Scarlet Witch . However , the idea that the Mind Stone might have act upon Thanos ' murderous programme is very entertaining nonetheless . It would fundamentally mean that the Mind Stone is what give Thanos his madness , and that he might have gone on to do large things and even ground a path to save his people had it never come into his possession and convince him that genocide was the only pick .
At any rate , the Mind Stone being a pestiferous effect behind Thanos ' origins is still a champion idea and would have had some key narration significance . After all , it was ultimately the first and last Infinity Stone the Mad Titan would come to collect before snatch his fingers in theMCU . However , it seems far more likely thatThanoshad already made his finish about balance and erasing half of all life long before he came into contact with the Mind Stone .
Custom Image by Kevin Erdmann
Source : Reddit / LoveWaffle1
